Why Do American Programmers Work Easier and Have Less Overtime Than Chinese Programmers?

An Enviable Comparison

I often see such comparisons online: American programmers leave at 5 PM, and their offices are as quiet as ghost towns on weekends. Meanwhile, here in China, offices are still brightly lit at 9 PM, and people often work on weekends.

Same job as programmers, why such a huge difference?

Although I don't have friends working in Silicon Valley, through various channels and my own observations and reflections, I've found that the reasons behind this are much more complex than imagined. It's not simply "the grass is greener on the other side," but involves differences in law, culture, economics, and other aspects.

The Legal Defense Line - A Real Difference

In the US, labor laws have strict regulations on overtime. The Fair Labor Standards Act requires 1.5x pay for work exceeding 40 hours. Although programmers are classified as "exempt employees," companies don't dare go too far because employees have strong rights awareness and will sue at the drop of a hat.

Moreover, union power in the US is relatively strong. If companies make employees work overtime long-term, they face significant legal risks and reputation damage.

Looking at China, although the Labor Law also stipulates overtime compensation, the enforcement... you know. 996 is packaged as "struggle culture," and overtime becomes a symbol of "dedication." Employee rights protection costs are high, and often it's "voluntary" overtime.

Legal provisions are one thing, enforcement is another.

Corporate Culture: What Really Matters?

American companies focus more on results and efficiency. As long as you can complete tasks on time with quality assurance, companies generally don't care when you leave or where you work.

A programmer working at Google shared online that they have a colleague who leaves at 3 PM every day, but writes high-quality code with few bugs, and nobody complains. Because this person is efficient and finishes work before 3 PM.

Many Chinese companies still stick to the "attendance" mindset, believing that staying longer at the company means working harder. Even if you finish tasks in the morning, you still have to "pretend to be busy" until closing time.

Worse yet, many managers treat overtime as a manifestation of "team cohesion." If you leave early, you're "not fitting in" and "lack team spirit." I really can't understand this logic.

Supply and Demand in the Talent Market

Excellent programmers are relatively scarce in the US, especially experienced ones. To retain talent, companies must provide good working environments. If you make people work overtime every day, they'll quit immediately and easily find better jobs.

Silicon Valley has a high job-hopping rate, and competition between companies for talent is fierce. In this environment, companies naturally don't dare be too harsh.

China has a large number of programmers, especially junior and mid-level ones. Companies have more choices, and employees have relatively weaker bargaining power. You don't want to work overtime? No problem, plenty of people are willing to.

Although senior programmers are also scarce, overall it's still a buyer's market. This gives companies more initiative.

Different Business Environment Rhythms

The US tech industry is relatively mature, with many companies having passed the crazy expansion phase and entered stable development. In this situation, companies focus more on sustainable development and won't over-exploit employees.

Moreover, American investors are more rational and won't give you higher valuations just because you work more overtime. They focus more on actual things like business models, technical barriers, and market prospects.

Many Chinese companies are still in rapid expansion phases, especially internet companies. "Speed is the only martial art that cannot be defeated" - whoever can occupy the market faster can survive. In this environment, time is money, speed is life. Overtime becomes a "necessary sacrifice."

Cultural Differences Are Also Key

American culture emphasizes individual rights and work-life balance. Work is work, life is life, with clear boundaries. It's normal not to reply to your boss's messages after work.

They believe that if someone can't even manage their own time well, how can they manage work well?

Chinese culture emphasizes collective interests and dedication. "The company is a big family," "for team goals" - these sound warm but often become reasons for overtime.

Moreover, social competition in China is fierce, and everyone has anxiety about "falling behind if not advancing." Not working overtime makes people feel they're not working hard enough and will be surpassed by others. This internal competition is really exhausting.

The Vicious Cycle of Technical Debt

American companies generally focus on code quality and development standards. Investing more time upfront in architecture design, code reviews, and testing results in much lower maintenance costs later. Their development processes are mature with high automation levels, solving many repetitive tasks with tools.

Many Chinese companies pursue rapid iteration with "go live first, optimize later." This leads to accumulating technical debt, requiring lots of time to "pay back" later. Many companies have insufficiently standardized development processes with low automation levels, forcing programmers to spend lots of time on repetitive work.

Management Level Gaps

Most technical managers in the US have professional management training, knowing how to arrange work reasonably, evaluate workloads, and improve team efficiency. They trust data and processes more than "gut feeling" decisions.

Many technical managers in China are "career changers" promoted from programmers, lacking professional management training. They often still use technical thinking to manage teams. "I came up this way," "young people should suffer more" - these thoughts are common.

Compensation Structure Impact

American company compensation structures have a large equity component. Employees care more about long-term company development rather than short-term overtime performance. The US tax system is also friendly to equity gains, further strengthening long-term incentives.

Chinese company compensation is still mainly cash-based, with insufficient equity incentive adoption. Employees care more about current income and are easily influenced by short-term incentives like "overtime pay."

But America Isn't Paradise Either

After saying so much good about America, it's not perfect either.

Startups also have overtime culture, and certain traditional industries (like investment banking, consulting) also have serious overtime. Health insurance tied to jobs makes job-hopping costs actually quite high. Regional differences are significant - not everywhere is like Silicon Valley.

Moreover, China is slowly improving: more companies are starting to value work-life balance, younger generation employees have increasing rights awareness, the government is strengthening labor law enforcement, some big companies are canceling 996 and implementing flexible work systems.

What Can We Do

Honestly, the overall environment is hard to change short-term, but we can still do something:

Improve your technical abilities and irreplaceability to have more choices. Learn to plan time reasonably and improve work efficiency - don't fall into "busy work" traps. Consider corporate culture when choosing companies - money is important, but health is more important. Learn to say "no" when appropriate - don't agree to everything.

Final Thoughts

American programmers working easily with less overtime isn't because they're "lazy," but because the entire system design is more reasonable. Legal protection is in place, corporate culture is healthy, market environment is fair, and management levels are professional.

We can't simply envy or complain - the key is thinking about how to improve our situation under current conditions.

After all, programmers are people too and need life. We code for better living, not live to code.

Efficiency is more important than time, results more important than process, and health more important than anything.

---

When do you think China's overtime culture will improve? How's the situation at your company? Let's chat in the comments!